Animal agriculture has changed dramatically in recent decades. From the practice of concentrated animal confinement on factory farms to the massive land use required to produce feed crops for livestock and pollution generated by poorly regulated waste management and slaughterhouses, the current U.S. food system is unsustainable and a leading contributor to environmental degradation.
Most of the 9 billion farmed animals in the United States are confined in concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs), which churn out meat, poultry, egg and dairy products at an unmanageable rate. The most extreme confinement practices — battery cages, gestation crates and veal crates — have been outlawed in a dozen states. Yet they largely continue as standard practices and are linked with poor animal welfare, risks to food and worker safety, air and water pollution, greenhouse gas emissions and threats to endangered species.
Since the 1950s U.S. meat and dairy production has more than doubled, while the number of operations has decreased by 80%. As a result greenhouse gas emissions from the agricultural sector have rapidly increased, with carbon dioxide emissions increasing by 16.2%, methane emissions by 14.4% and nitrous oxide by 7.3% in the past 30 years. Methane and nitrous oxide have as much as 36 and 298 times greater global warming potential, respectively, than CO2 over a 100-year period.
Along with the rise of CAFOs, emissions related to manure management have increased by 66% since 1990. Factory farms produced an estimated 13 times as much waste as the entire U.S. population in 2012. Unlike human waste, livestock waste is typically untreated and poorly managed.
The EPA estimates that pollution from CAFOs impairs 40% of rivers and streams in the United States.
The most common environmental threats from these facilities include:
With more than 70 million pigs populating the United States, and 5.36 million breeding sows, factory farms have implemented the practices of extreme confinement of mother pigs in gestation crates. These tight stalls prevent sows from turning around and contain no bedding — just slatted flooring for waste disposal.
In 2014, 93% of annual hog production was on operations with at least 5,000 head (compared to 27% in 1994). This shift toward more concentrated facilities has resulted in increases in water and air contamination and environmental impairment.
The increased concentration of hogs and breeding sows creates huge cesspools of waste that are currently disposed of by spraying them onto surrounding lands. The massive amounts of waste generated in limited geographic areas leads to intensive air and water pollution and related health risks for surrounding communities and wildlife.
For example, in Iowa, more than 10 billion gallons of liquid manure are applied to fields per year from the state’s more than 6,300 hog operations. State records show 800 manure spills between 1996 and 2012, and 750 out of 1,378 tested waterways were found to be impaired.
Most chickens spend their entire lives stocked in “battery cages,” in such high densities that they cannot exert their natural behaviors of nesting, roosting or even flapping their wings. Many chickens die from disease and stress related to overcrowded conditions. But the concentration of factory farming continues to encourage the use of these facilities.
The production of poultry has shifted over recent decades toward more concentrated facilities. The production of eggs has seen a related boom: Since 2011 top states have produced an additional 11.2 billion eggs in CAFO operations, including California, Ohio, Indiana, Missouri, Michigan, North Carolina and Texas. The number of egg-laying hens increased by nearly 25% between 1997 and 2012, and the size of egg operations has grown by nearly 75% since 1997.
Battery cage facilities produce high levels of air contamination from ammonia and hydrogen sulfide as well as volatile organic compounds and dust originating from chicken feathers, bedding and chicken manure. Pollutants spread from the chicken cages and fields to waterways, critical habitat areas, and local community houses, churches and schools.
In addition to large amounts of pesticide and pharmaceutical residues, bacteria, viruses, pathogens, parasites, protozoa, heavy metals and other trace elements, poultry waste is particularly high in toxic nutrients, and yet is usually untreated, stored and land-applied. Over 90% of poultry waste is disposed of through land applications. Erosion, non-agronomic waste applications, and rain can cause it to reach surface and groundwaters.
Release of these pollutants may result from intentional discharge, operation, maintenance, management and/or operation design problems. Waste-management systems can have spills, leaks, accidental discharges and reach surface water and/or groundwater.
The EPA has noted that rain falling on dry poultry manure left outside uncovered will likely transport pollutants into nearby soil, causing groundwater pollution and contaminating surface waters.
Calves are removed from their mothers to prevent suckling and chained in crates — 22 inches by 54 inches — without the ability to move or turn around. Preventing the animals from moving keeps their muscles anemic, and the calves are fed formula instead of mother’s milk.
Calf waste is distributed either through deep pit storage or flush. The floor of the crate is composed of slats directly above a storage pit or flush alley. This flooring does not adequately allow feces and urine to pass through, and animals end up standing and sleeping in their own feces, leading to the contraction of parasites, a virus or harmful bacteria. Diarrhea from dehydration is common and sometimes fatal.
The majority of veal operations use large volumes of water to flush manure from storage pits to lagoons. The remaining operations store manure in a large pit beneath the shed, which uses less water but results in a higher concentration of nutrients.
Calves are slaughtered between 4 to 5 months of age. But calves younger than 4 months are not included in greenhouse gas emission estimates, so the climate impact of veal production is unaccounted for.
Despite 40 years of Clean Water Act implementation, the Environmental Protection Agency still lacks data about where the nation’s CAFOs are located and which facilities discharge pollutants into waterways without required permits. The EPA states 40% of CAFOs are regulated under National Pollutant Discharge Elimination Systems (NPDES) while 75% discharge as a result of “standard operational profiles.”
This failure by the EPA to develop or maintain a CAFO inventory has meant that states must identify CAFOs and determine which are subject to regulation with little guidance or oversight from the agency. The lack of federal oversight leaves communities bearing the burden of the environmental impacts of industrial livestock production.
The Center has supported legislation in several states to ban the most extreme forms of confinement, which would be a step toward reducing the environmental burden on air, water and wildlife. We also support communities fighting against pollution and the increasing concentration of animal agriculture, such as opposing mega-dairies in Oregon and standing with communities in North Carolina fighting the public health threats from massive factory farms.
The lack of environmental protection in the meat and dairy industry isn’t just a problem at CAFOs — slaughterhouses are an enormous, and often ignored, source of pollution. For example, in 2018, slaughterhouses dumped 55 million pounds of toxic pollution into U.S. rivers and streams. The Center is working to close loopholes allowing slaughterhouses to contaminate waterways. We’re also fighting reckless line-speed waivers that increase threats to workers, animals and the environment. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we urged the U.S. Department of Agriculture to end the horrific and toxic “depopulation” practices that were responsible for untold cruelty and pollution as millions of carcasses were disposed of with no accountability.
Industrial meat and dairy production is devastating for the environment, animals and people. In addition to the communities harmed by CAFO and slaughterhouse pollution, the industry notoriously exploits its workers. Slaughterhouses and meatpacking facilities have been deemed the most dangerous jobs in the United States by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
People who work in these low-wage, dangerous jobs are often from already-marginalized communities. They’re more likely to lack access to healthy, sustainable food, more likely to be harmed by toxicity in food production, and less likely to be paid a living wage or have access to healthy food or healthcare. We support the rights and causes of those who grow, raise, transport, pack, prepare and provide food service.
CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY
P.O. BOX 710 . TUCSON, AZ 85702 . UNITED STATES
COPYRIGHT © 2021 . TAKE EXTINCTION OFF YOUR PLATE . CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY . ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
THE CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY IS A 501(C)(3) REGISTERED CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION. TAX ID: 27-3943866